Luck Pillar clashes Year Branch: Year-Branch clash is palace talk, not a rewrite of origin
Luck Pillar clashes Year Branch: some Luck step’s branch forms a six-clash with the Year Branch (子午, 丑未, 寅申, 卯酉, 辰戌, 巳亥). The Year Branch is often linked to ancestors, origin, or the early-life palace, so folk talk turns a Year clash into “origin changes.” This site reads it as structural agitation: first check whether the clashed Year Branch and the Luck Branch are favorable or avoid, then talk palace; never merge Year clash, Month clash, and Day clash into one sentence.
Cast your chart and see your Luck Pillar clashes Year Branch →Free, no sign-up
Why is first-eight Year clash 68.2% rather than 100%?
At least one Year-Branch clash in the first 8 steps is 68.2% (1363 / 2000); per-step rate is 8.5%. Luck starts on the Month Branch’s neighbor, and the distance between Year and Month differs by chart—whether eight steps reach the Year Branch’s clash mate is not fixed.
First Luck itself clashes the Year Branch 8.2% (164 charts). First Luck lands next to the Month Branch; only some charts place the Year clash there. It is lower than Month clash’s certain 100%, slightly above Day clash’s 65.5%—three different numbers, not interchangeable.
Year Branch clashed: favor/avoid first, or origin talk first?
Among hit steps, the clashed Year Branch is favorable 48.7%, unfavorable 37.6%; the Luck Branch is favorable 55.7%, unfavorable 31.1%. Year-Branch favor/avoid sits closer to even, unlike the Month Branch’s avoid-heavy split—so never default to “Year clash = bad.”
Hit charts are strong 45.0%, weak 54.7%. Clash does not favor strength or weakness. Year clash can support ancestor/origin-palace associations, but that is palace talk—not a substitute for favor/avoid.
Keep it apart from Month clash and Day clash
Month clash agitates the month command; Day clash often invites spouse-palace talk; Year clash is where ancestor/origin-palace talk belongs. One Luck step may clash only one of them—name the palace first.
Contrast first-8 clash Month 100%, clash Day 65.5%, clash Year 68.2%. Hit rates differ, yet the reading is the same: check clashed branch and Luck Branch favor/avoid, then talk decade themes.
Want to see it on your own chart? Open the free BaZi calculator.
Data: how common is a Luck clash with the Year Branch?
In 2000 charts over the first 8 steps, at least one Year-Branch clash is 68.2% (1363); first Luck itself is 8.2% (164); per-step rate is 8.5% (1363 / 16000).
Hit charts are strong 45.0%, weak 54.7%. The clashed Year Branch is favorable 48.7%, unfavorable 37.6%; the Luck Branch is favorable 55.7%, unfavorable 31.1%. Contrast first-8 clash Month 100%, clash Day 65.5%.
Simulated charts: our BaZi calculator generated 2000 random birth times (years 1950–2010 uniform, random clock, balanced gender, Beijing true solar time, seed 2026110210), cast each chart and judged strength and the Useful element by traditional rules, then counted the results. These are simulated results, not a survey of real people and not a measure of prediction accuracy. Luck clash Year Branch = first 8 Luck Branches six-clash Year Branch; first Luck counted alone; clash-branch elements vs natal favor/avoid; Luck clash Month and Day on the same sample as contrast. Calculation version: our BaZi calculator after the Oct 15, 2026 update (the same rules the site uses now; rechecked with site version v73 on Oct 20, 2026), random seed 20261014. To reproduce: rerun the same version with the same seed and the results match exactly; you can check any single chart by entering the same birth time in our BaZi calculator.
At a glance
| Item | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| ≥1 hit in first 8 steps | 68.2% | 1363 / 2000 |
| First Luck clashes Year | 8.2% | 164 charts |
| Per-step hit rate | 8.5% | 1363 / 16000 steps |
| Contrast: clash Month / Day | 100% / 65.5% | same sample |
- Six-clash
- 子午, 丑未, 寅申, 卯酉, 辰戌, 巳亥
- Year Branch
- Ancestor/origin-palace association
- First Luck
- First decade after onset
- Month clash
- Month command weight, contrast 100%
Two real charts
庚子 己丑 庚戌 乙酉 (male, 1961-01-17 17:15 Beijing, true solar 17:20)
Year Branch 子; fifth Luck 甲午; 子午 clash; strong. True solar 1961-01-17 17:20; about age 46, entering in 2006.
Useful Fire, favor Wood/Water, avoid Earth. 午 Fire clashes 子 Water; with the Year Branch on the favorable side, the clash reads as the origin palace pushed. Still check the whole 甲午 step and the annual pillars—do not write it as changing your origin.
庚子 戊子 辛巳 乙未 (female, 1960-12-19 14:30 Beijing, true solar 14:17)
Year Branch 子; sixth Luck 壬午; 子午 clash; weak. True solar 1960-12-19 14:17; about age 56, entering in 2015.
Useful Earth, favor Metal/Fire, avoid Water/Wood. A weak chart meeting a Year clash first asks whether Resource and Peer can support the Day Master; with 子 Water on the avoid side, read the clash as an old structure agitated.
Common view vs. our view
| Common view | Our view | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Luck clash Year = origin rewritten | Clash is palace agitation, not a fate rewrite | Year-Branch favor/avoid is near even |
| Year clash is always bad | Clashed Year Branch is favorable 48.7% | Check favor/avoid before ancestor talk |
| Year and Month clash are the same size | Month 100%, Year 68.2% | Hit rates differ |
| Year clash beats Day clash | Year 68.2%, Day 65.5% | A few points—do not exaggerate |
FAQ
Does a Luck clash with the Year Branch mean an origin change?
You can talk ancestor/origin-palace associations, but do not decide a change from one clash. Check clashed Year Branch and Luck Branch favor/avoid, then the real situation.
How common is a Year clash in the first eight steps?
68.2% hit at least once in the sample; per-step about 8.5%; first Luck itself about 8.2%.
How does it differ from Month clash?
Month clash agitates the month command and hits almost everyone in eight steps; Year clash is ancestor/origin-palace talk at about 68.2%.
Why can’t a Year clash directly mean bad?
The clashed Year Branch is favorable 48.7%, unfavorable 37.6%—near even. Outcome still follows favor/avoid and the whole Luck step.
Common mistakes
- Luck clash Year Branch rewrites your origin: clash is palace agitation; origin and family background still follow the natal chart and reality, not one clash character.
- Year clash is always bad: the clashed Year Branch is favorable 48.7%, unfavorable 37.6%—close to even, so do not default to bad.
- Year, Month, and Day clash can share one sentence: the three palaces carry different weight and different hit rates; write them separately.